November 19, 2026
In October, Old Town Construction was laying a water main for Phase 6 of Provenance. Pathfinder Drive was scheduled to close to through traffic for a week, with local access kept open. The pipe will serve 60 single-family lots on about 14 acres on the south side of Pathfinder Drive, two blocks west of Airport Road.
That says a lot about the neighborhood a buyer would join today. Provenance has prices well above the rest of West Lafayette. Much of the neighborhood laid out in its plan has won approval in the past two years and is still filling in. So a buyer who pays the premium now is paying for a plan, and the useful thing to know is what that plan contains.
Old Town Design Group's Provenance page lists single-family homes starting at $650,000 and townhomes starting at $485,000. Indiana REALTORS data for West Lafayette's 47906 ZIP code put the October 2026 median sale price at $427,500. Across Tippecanoe County, the October 2026 median was $320,000.
Elsewhere in West Lafayette, a new house costs much less. At Millbrook, Arbor Homes advertised plans from $297,995 to $357,995 and Silverthorne Homes advertised plans from $385,995 to $451,995, as posted on their sites in mid-November 2026. All of these, Provenance included, are advertised starting prices, not closed sales. Even so, the cheapest Provenance townhome starts above the most expensive Millbrook plan on that list.
The resale market around Provenance has been softening. For the three weeks through early November 2026, homes in 47906 sold at an average of 92.6% of their original asking price, and that figure was trending down. For the week of November 2, median days on market was 51. The ZIP had 3.6 months of inventory in October. A buyer comparing an existing West Lafayette home with a Provenance new build therefore has room to negotiate on one and a premium to justify on the other. Our earlier look at how West Lafayette prices are splitting by price band explains why one median can't settle that comparison.
The premium is easier to judge once you know what is coming.
The Provenance Planned Development was created in 2019 with eight phases. In June 2025, Tippecanoe County planning staff told the Area Plan Commission that Phases 1 and 2 were the only ones built out. Those first phases are a single-family and townhome section plus apartments, which the Purdue Exponent reported were mostly occupied by students under a contract with the university.
The phases after those two will add brownstones, plex units, single-family streets and a clubhouse, and all of them have gone before the Area Plan Commission or the City Council since late 2024.
In November 2024, Based in Lafayette reported that Old Town had paused a rezoning request after homeowners objected. The request would have replaced the 88 homes and townhomes originally planned for Phases 3 through 5 with as many as 197 brownstone-style apartments and townhouses. The pause did not last. The West Lafayette City Council passed Ordinance 03-2025 for Phases 3 through 5 by a 7–0 vote at its February 3, 2025 meeting.
The Area Plan Commission later approved the final detailed plans for Phases 3 and 4, 14–0. The plans call for 195 units of three-story brownstones and two-story plex units, with 293 parking spaces split between surface lots and garages, on the southwest corner of Airport Road and Harrison Street. Old Town's Greg Koziol told the commission the company had received FAA approval for a temporary crane and was excited to get the project off the ground. Trailway Boulevard, just to the south, is being extended to give access to these phases and later to Phase 6.
That is the main change for anyone buying into Provenance now. The approved plan adds about twice the original number of homes for those phases, in denser building types, a short walk from the existing single-family streets.
The developer has said who those units are meant for. Curtis Sattison, Old Town's vice president of development, told the Purdue Exponent that the new homes are "really tailored and designed for young professionals, young families," and that Provenance is meant to house people who "live, work and play in Discovery Park and around Discovery Park." The council approved the phases with written commitments attached, and those are part of the public record in the February 3, 2025 council minutes.
Phase 6 is the part of the plan that adds detached houses. Its revised layout keeps 60 single-family lots, eight of them front-loaded and 52 served by alleys, and adds a new street, Luminescence Drive. Old Town's Greg Koziol told the Area Plan Commission that the changes removed several dead-end alleys and created more points of access. The commission recommended it 12–0 on June 18, 2025. The City Council passed it as Ordinance 29-2025, 8–0, on July 7, 2025. The commission approved the final detailed plans 6–0 on November 5, 2025. The water main work this fall is the next step after those approvals.
Old Town lists its Provenance homes as built without basements and at 1,600 square feet or more. A buyer moving from an older West Lafayette house with a basement will want to plan storage around that.
Some of the premium goes to amenities that already exist. The Lawrence opened in the restored Beck Barn on February 2, 2026, with 113 indoor seats, 45 on the patio and event space for up to 200. Purdue Research Foundation held a ribbon cutting for the upgraded Squirrel Park on June 11, 2026, which added green space, walkways and play areas. We covered both in our look at the barn and the park. Old Town lists Indie Coffee Roasters on site and a community clubhouse with a pool, cabanas and a fitness center scheduled to open in 2027. Discovery Park District lists Bindley Bioscience Center, Birck Nanotechnology Center, the Convergence Center and Purdue University Airport among its neighbors. In April 2025, Purdue announced an Ascension St. Vincent neighborhood care facility at Airport Road and U.S. 231, with urgent care, imaging, labs and primary care.
The restaurant, the park and the research buildings are in place today. The clubhouse, the 195 Phase 3 and 4 units and the 60 Phase 6 houses are approved, and Phase 6 had crews installing its water main this fall. A Provenance owner who buys now will live beside that work until the neighborhood reaches its finished plan.
For a buyer who wants new construction near Purdue and plans to stay long enough to see the clubhouse open and the brownstones fill in, the price makes sense: it pays for a walkable district next to Purdue's research park, with next phases the developer has designed for professionals and families. For a buyer who mainly wants square footage in West Lafayette, the same budget goes further in a 47906 resale market where homes have recently sold below original asking price. A Millbrook new build costs well under Provenance's starting price.
It helps to ask Old Town directly about HOA dues, the clubhouse schedule and which lots face the Phase 3 and 4 construction before you choose a home. Those answers affect your daily life there more than the starting price does.
Who builds homes in Provenance? The Purdue Exponent reported that the expansion is being built on land bought from Purdue Research Foundation and funded by Old Town Design Group. Old Town is the builder named on the current for-sale homes.
Are the existing Provenance apartments part of the new phases? No. The Purdue Exponent reported that the existing apartments were sold to Core Spaces and are occupied mostly by students under a university contract. The newer phases are designed for professionals and families.
Is the clubhouse open? Old Town lists it as scheduled to open in 2027.
If you are comparing a Provenance home with an existing house elsewhere in West Lafayette, Gibson Realty Group can help you compare the two on price, timing and what will be built around each. If you own in West Lafayette now and want to know what your home would bring toward a move, start with a free home valuation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
A genuine love for the community paired with professional experience ensures a personalized and thoughtful approach to every client need.